Everyone has seen the reports of the incident at Camp Liberty recently.
I have to admit no traumatic stress I may have endured has ever warranted in me a desire to commit acts of violence as much as watching reporters and others making comments about the subject of
PTSD and its supposed role in this case.
First of all there are still a number of things we do not know surrounding this particular case. Knowing how long investigations can take, we will not likely know the specifics for some time. Until then, everyone is irresponsibly making conclusions without any information.
Reports surrounding the Camp Liberty incident have stressed the importance of finding out what led to this tragic incident. The media seems to assume combat deployments lead servicemen to commit inappropriate acts of violence, (appropriate being the lawful elimination of enemy forces), as if it
wasn’t the shooter’s fault, but the stress of multiple tours which made him do it. This infuriates many of us who have and continue to serve on multiple combat tours. The assumption that all veterans coming home could snap at any moment spraying the area with automatic gunfire is as bigoted a concept as any I have ever heard.
The other implication, that we in the service
aren’t taking care of our troops, is a slap in the face to those of us who consider duty and loyalty the highest of human virtues. Our very martial culture revolves around looking out for the guy on our left and right. Marines have waged entire battles in an effort to retrieve the bodies of their slain comrades. Leaving a comrade behind on the field of mental illness or traumatic stress seems equally distasteful.
The stigma of
PTSD in the military has been addressed for the last couple of years. In my experience those who work and live closest to the service member know when they need help. At the very least, fellow Marines and family members know there is something wrong. Sometimes the command has to encourage service members to get treatment; however if the service member
doesn’t participate fully he will not get better.
Treatment failure sometimes has more to do with patients resisting treatment options and not a lack of help or commands being unwilling to get their troops care. Life is easier when you are victim and nothing is your fault after all. That and you don’t have to do any real work and still collect a free pay check.
Some fail because of their refusal to participate fully in treatment programs which are established and work adhered to properly. Marines have also fail treatment because they want it on their terms and convenience and not according to guidelines based on professionally designed standards of care. To me this is no different than refusing to wear a cast properly after breaking a bone. You don’t get better unless you do what the doctor prescribes.
Thus each and every time someone
doesn’t want to take responsibility for their actions, they point their finger at the military claiming they
aren’t getting help. It’s a convenient scapegoat.
Others have had successful treatment because once they recognized they had a problem they did what was necessary to get better. It’s kind of how we train them to attack problems and overcome obstacles in the first place: eliminate the threat; protect the force; accomplish the mission. It works, go figure.
Abdication of personal responsibility is not a side effect of
PTSD. I have seen plenty of
PTSD paperwork written by doctors that clearly reiterate time and again that patients are still responsible for their personal conduct. Read here: people with
PTSD still know the difference between right and wrong.
Blaming multiple deployments or traumatic stress for someone’s actions is just another way of enabling people to avoid the consequences of their own tragic decisions. Seeing the media and others use this particular case to highlight their own agenda tightens my jaws like a vise.
In the Camp Liberty case, we simply do not know what really happened yet or why. As far as I’m concerned the root cause is certainly not
PTSD. Stress, traumatic or otherwise, it is not an excuse for anyone to commit acts of murder.
I realize that the idea of personal accountability is offensive to some in the 21st Century, but it is alive and well in the camp of the
Praetorians.
Post your thoughts in comments. Intelligent dialogue is always welcome.